- What's the difference between copper, brass and kansa?
- All three are copper-based. Copper is copper on its own and polishes reddish-orange. Brass is copper with zinc and looks yellow. Kansa, or bell metal, is copper with tin, traditionally 78% copper to 22% tin, with a warm gold-pink tone and a clear ring when struck. None of them sticks to a magnet.
- Does a magnet test prove my brass is real?
- No, but it catches the most common fake. Copper, brass and bronze aren't magnetic; brass-plated iron is. If a "brass" diya grabs a fridge magnet, it's iron with a coating. Passing proves less, because some stainless steels aren't magnetic either. Use it with the checks below.
- How do I spot brass plating?
- Plating wears off where a piece gets rubbed and handled. Turn it over and look at the base, the rim and the edges. If a different colour shows through there, it's a thin coat over another metal. Don't scratch a piece you haven't bought; the wear spots tell you enough.
- How can I tell if kansa is genuine?
- Three things together. Tap it: hold the bowl on your fingertips and flick the rim, and real kansa gives a clear, sharp ring. Feel it: real kansa is heavy for its size, and a piece that's light or evenly shiny all over is often stamped brass or low-grade bronze. Look at it: hand-beaten kansa carries small, uneven hammer marks.
- Is kansa the same as bronze?
- Kansa is a type of bronze, but not every bronze is kansa. Bronze can be anywhere from 60:40 to 95:5 copper to tin. Kansa means the 78:22 mix. If a shop says "bronze", ask the tin content.
- Is "German silver" a kind of silver?
- No. It's the old name for nickel silver, a mix of copper, nickel and zinc. It contains no silver, so it shouldn't be priced like silver.
- Can I cook sour food in brass or copper?
- Only if the inside is tinned. The US FDA Food Code says bare copper and copper alloys like brass shouldn't touch food with a pH below 6, which includes lemon, tomato and tamarind. The traditional fix is kalai, a coat of pure tin inside the vessel. Hyderabad's kalaiwalas say it lasts about six to eight months of regular use. A plain copper lota is fine for water.
- Can I eat off a kansa thali every day?
- Yes, kansa thalis, bowls and glasses are made for serving. Kansa makers advise short cooking only for sour dishes, and a tinned vessel for long simmers.
- How do I avoid overpaying at a metal shop?
- Ask the weight in grams and divide the price by it, so you compare like with like. Ask for the alloy to be written on the bill. Treat a big discount as a question: a kansa set at half the usual rate is lighter, a different alloy, or plated. Hand-beaten pieces fairly cost more than machine-pressed ones of the same weight.
- How do I clean brass, copper and kansa after Diwali?
- Wash by hand with a soft sponge and mild dish soap, don't soak overnight, dry straight away, and keep it out of the dishwasher. For shine, rub with tamarind pulp or half a lemon dipped in salt, then rinse and dry. Black tarnish is cosmetic; green spots are corrosion and worth cleaning. Skip the salt on anything plated or given an antique finish.
- Where does this information come from?
- Pages checked on 3 Nov 2026: Britannica on brass (britannica.com/technology/brass-alloy), bell metal (britannica.com/technology/bell-metal) and nickel silver (britannica.com/technology/nickel-silver); the Canadian Conservation Institute on recognising metals (canada.ca/en/conservation-institute/services/care-objects/metals/basic-care-recognizing-metals-corrosion-products.html); the US FDA Food Code §4-101.14, as quoted by Iowa's Alcoholic Beverages Division (revenue.iowa.gov/bulletin/2017-07-28/use-copper-mugs-serving-alcoholic-beverages); Telangana Today on Hyderabad's kalaiwalas (telanganatoday.com/hyderabads-last-kalaiwalas-keep-centuries-old-copper-tinning-tradition-alive); UNESCO on the Thathera craft (ich.unesco.org/en/RL/00845); Kansawala (kansawalas.com) and Zishta (zishta.com/blogs/bodha/kansa-vs-bronze-indian-alloy-traditional-cookware-serveware) on kansa; The Week on Assam's GI tags (theweek.in/wire-updates/national/2024/03/31/cal5-as-gi-tags.html). Maker details are from their ScoutLoft listings.